CarMax reviews

3.5

59% would recommend to a friend

(8,182 total reviews)
avatar

Keith Barr

44% approve of CEO

49% positive business outlook

CarMax has an employee rating of 3.5 out of 5 stars, based on 8,182 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The CarMax employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Commerce de détail et de gros industry (3.5 stars).

Reviews by job title

8K reviews
4.0
Jan 4, 2019
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

- Can't speak for all analysts, but my team specifically had some of the smartest people I've ever worked with - Analysts are highly valued by leadership, so lots of opportunity to work on highly visible and interesting stuff - Great work-life balance (depends on team though, some are more "always on" than others) - Casual office with nice facilities (nice gym, food onsite)

Cons

- Doesn't feel like there is much potential for growth above Sr Analyst level. Very few roles at the Sr Mgr+ level and little turnover for those in those roles make it feel like if you were to reach that level in potential, they wouldn't actually have anywhere to put you. In the last couple years, they introduced the Manager level role for analysts (used to go directly from Sr Analyst to Sr Mgr) so this has semi-alleviated the problem but it still feels like there's a ceiling - Performance management is really lacking. No real visibility on how you are performing comparatively to your peers or how you are tracking towards promotion. No real goal setting or progress tracking, just kind of got a "good job" at the end of the year. Like performance management at any job though, this varies by manager. - Pay/benefits aren't up to par. Can definitely be paid to do the same job at other places in the area. - Richmond is kind of lame, especially for early/mid 20's crowd. Especially sucks that the main office is ~30 mins west of downtown

3.0
Oct 7, 2018

Sales Consultant

Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Flexible hours, College reimbursement program for both part time and full time. Great place to work if you are a college student and need a flexible schedule. For a part time job, you also have the potential of making more money then you would at most other part time retail jobs. Also one of if not the only car sales position where you can work part time. Most traditional car dealerships require you to work full time (based off of personnel experience).

Cons

Commissioned based job with no base salary. If you do end making less than minimum wage CarMax will pay you at least the minimum wage which, you have to pay them back on your next check. So they really only loan you minimum wage if you don't produce any sales(better than not making any money though, like is the case at some other commission based jobs). CarMax runs off a flat rate commission pay system that can be less than in traditional sales. The way the company justifies this, is by saying that CarMax produces higher foot traffic than traditional dealerships. So you end up selling double the cars than a traditional sales person but you end up making the same or less than traditional sales. A sales consultant at CarMax is has more responsibilities than a traditional sales person. Here a sales is responsible for the entire transaction from start to finish (including doing the financing). So double the work for half the pay. Also because CarMax has the no hassle policy and encourages people to come in and browse we also end up with a higher volume of less serious shoppers, which usually leads to you working with somebody for an entire day or a few days for no money at all.

2.0
Jun 18, 2018
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Wearing shorts to work is great. “The Culture” is promoted to ta great extent and has been rated “best” to work at 14 yrs in a row. Discounts on vehicles 3 times a year. Most employees are different outside of work because there isn’t the looming manager just dying to look good for hauling in an associate for saying something off the cuff.

Cons

I wish I had read more of the “buyer” reviews before quitting my job, taking a pay cut, and destroying my self esteem. Impossible to navigate the politics that run the purchasing dept. Constant “feedback” loop results in unnecessary negative conversations for the sake of saying feedback is being given. Individual development plans (IDP’s) are a constant for everyone — apparently they think this shows managements ability to manage people (which most senior managers lack). Zero ability to report negative experience without retaliation. Every conversation EVERY SINGLE ONE with someone you haven’t guaranteed a personal friendship with is reported to a manager. It’s encouraged. While you are in training you are viewed as “less than” and you have no voice. No matter the experience you bring- you know nothing and you will be treated as such by every other person in the purchasing department. Senior management can not admit to faults - even when presented with hard evidence, and that breeds hypocrisy, lying, and suck-up teachers-pet types being given leeway for any rule infraction.

Viewing 97 - 99 of 8,182 Reviews

Glassdoor has 8,351 CarMax reviews submitted anonymously by CarMax employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if CarMax is right for you.