CarMax reviews

3.5

59% would recommend to a friend

(8,182 total reviews)
avatar

Keith Barr

44% approve of CEO

49% positive business outlook

CarMax has an employee rating of 3.5 out of 5 stars, based on 8,182 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The CarMax employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Commerce de détail et de gros industry (3.5 stars).

Reviews by job title

8K reviews
1.0
Jun 24, 2018

Don’t bother

Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

The people are mostly nice.

Cons

They just let go of 79 buyers to restructure the department. They are going for quantity over quality. I’m literally an appraisal robot. The micromanaging and constant feedback will destroy your confidence. There is no growth or future in purchasing as they are hiring hourly associates who can do it cheaper but not better.

3.0
Sep 12, 2016

My, my, where to start?

Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Honestly, the people I work with and have worked with in the past 2.5yrs, are the best people I have ever met in my life! When my son and I couldn't afford Christmas last year (we will get to that in a moment), the stepped up and filled my trunk, by surprise, with gifts for him and I, as well as with Christmas food. It brought me to tears! They are incredible and I couldn't have made it through the last year without them.

Cons

Now for the cons... 1) The pay is the worst I've seen in any sales job I've ever done. 2 weeks ago, I OWED the company money for a 50hr work week because I had returns and couldn't get a good deal to close to save my life. I have NEVER had a company make me pay them to work for them. 2) There is so much micromanaging that it constantly feels like I'm suffocating in needless busy work and training paperwork. This can be in the form of eoffice forms that take more time to full out than the actual call, or monthly file reviews that bring no value to my training. 3) Unpaid weekly trainings that can last an hour or more rarely bring anything but frustration. Unpaid lockups at night means I'm leaving sometimes an hour or hour and a half after my shift ends. Unpaid "merchandising" of cars that other departments dump into the wrong part of the retail lot. Unpaid this, unpaid that... blah blah blah. 4) Appraisals. Appraisals are the worst. I have zero control over the number that comes back from the appraisers, yet the survey dings me, the customer hates me, the amount I'm paid for the time spent doing the appraisal only comes in if they sell, and only if they sell without buying something else. If they trade in a vehicle my workload doubles for NOTHING EXTRA. Come on yall, that's bull. 5) If you want to move up, be a man, and be ready to kiss upper management man-butt. As a female, it is nearly impossible for them to take me seriously. I have more experience than half the jack wagons that are managers here, and yet I can't seem to get them to even entertain the idea of me advancing my career.

4.0
Feb 4, 2016
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

A company with integrity, something that's unheard of in the car buying industry. Great associates, fun work environment, and a management team that truly cares about you as a person. They also provide you with a great benefits package, which includes company contributions. If this means more than money to you, then Carmax is the place to work.

Cons

Non-competetive hourly wage (this is the ONLY reason I left the company). Yearly merit increase has a cap of 3.5%. The only way to make a decent living is to move into a salaried position. Growth opportunities ARE there for the taking, but their interview process for growth candidates is grueling. Unless you are able to sell yourself, there's a distinct possibility you won't pass MAP (Management Assessment Panel). I've found that the best "talkers" are the ones that pass MAP, not necessarily the most qualified. The assessment panel consists of 3 or 4 senior management employees that have never met the growth candidate before. They assess the candidate solely on the full day of questions that are conducted at a regional location. The candidate also compiles a presentation "selling" himself on why he should move up with the company. The panel has no idea how the candidate handles day to day activities in the store. P.S. This is not a rant from a previous employee that didn't pass MAP. I was a growth candidate, but declined the opportunity due to the MAP process. I worked at Carmax for over 3 years and saw entirely too many valuable employees FAIL the assessment while undeserving employees PASS the assessment all because of their ability to sell themselves ( AKA: lie about their core values and work ethic).

Viewing 85 - 87 of 8,182 Reviews

Glassdoor has 8,351 CarMax reviews submitted anonymously by CarMax employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if CarMax is right for you.