Paychex reviews

3.1

45% would recommend to a friend

(5,990 total reviews)
avatar

John Gibson

47% approve of CEO

45% positive business outlook

Paychex has an employee rating of 3.1 out of 5 stars, based on 5,990 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The Paychex employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Informatique industry (3.9 stars).

Reviews by job title

6K reviews
1.0
Jul 10, 2025

Run!

Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Remote work Benefits Co-workers Remote work

Cons

Extreme Micromanagement High Turnover Horrible reputation in market Job threatened on a daily basis Zero autonomy Unable to do my job due to manager trying to do my job. Incompetent manager. Boss calls outside of working hours and on weekends Rumor mill- SMB sales to be dissolved and sent to inside sales

1.0
Jul 8, 2025

Your just a number

Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

You are primarily viewed as just a number. Working at MPSC can be quite challenging; clients are demanding, and the workload can feel like a revolving door. The company struggles to retain employees, and the job often falls short of the hype. You're typically underpaid and overworked. While there are promotions intended to motivate you, they often feel inadequate. The company frequently tries to entice employees with monetary incentives, perhaps as compensation for the unrealistically high expectations set each year. Your service level agreement (SLA) metrics are adjusted annually, making it more difficult to achieve your goals. If you fail to meet your sales targets or the number of referrals, it can jeopardize your entire year’s performance, resulting in no bonuses or raises. For example, if the requirement was 20 last year, it could rise to 24 this year and may continue to increase at the discretion of upper management. Various incentive programs throughout the year aim to compensate for missed bonuses or pay increases, but the demands are still high. This role is extremely stressful and comes with a high turnover rate. You manage a portfolio of clients where expectations are elevated. Your responsibilities include overseeing everything for your clients from payroll to retirement plans, 401(k)s, general ledger management, time and attendance, time clock troubleshooting and more. You serve as the primary contact for these clients. For issues beyond your scope, you are expected to coordinate with the relevant departments to resolve them. Even if clients are unhappy with Paychex, it falls on you to address their concerns. Internal partners may also reach out to you about client issues, adding to your workload. Your book of business can consist of anywhere from 110 to over 165 clients, with some clients managing multiple locations. For instance, one client may have 13 locations, each housing between 25 to 300 employees. One of the most challenging aspects of this job is that, regardless of your hard work or if you meet all your metrics, if you falter in any one area, you will not receive any raises or bonuses. In contrast, at ADP, if you fail to meet expectations across the board, they at least acknowledge your efforts with a small reward. Unfortunately, Paychex does not offer the same recognition. I've also observed discrepancies in pay among account managers when they start. The pay can vary depending on the interviewers’ preferences, resulting in some new hires earning more than others. Interestingly, those who began with higher pay often no longer work here, while those with lower starting salaries have remained. Pros you get with the right manager your day can be amazing

Cons

Cons you’re looked at as a number

2.0
Jul 7, 2025

The Power of…..Simplicity?

Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

I have made amazing friends at Paychex- the kind that last well past the expiration date of the job. Great trauma bonding friendships!

Cons

Paychex touts the “power of simplicity” which is ironic considering every single thing that should be simple is made increasingly complicated. You will speak Paychexese- a labyrinth of acronyms so prolific, people just speak in letters. “I put ESR in CPQ and it shows up on the EFS but not the MSA- should I go to my DSM or DSA?” They also change the names of things- so people just add the new name to the original name. *HRPRO for example: “they are on PAS/Premier/HRsolutions/ASO/HR PRO” I often fantasized about being the person that renamed things at Paychex—-dream job??? Maybe. Paychex leadership has the ability to gaslight like nobody’s business. It truly is a master class in corporate spin selling that makes you feel like the issue is you (not Paychex), that Paychex is the best company to work for, that you are in the best division in the company and people are lining up out the door to take your spot. You question yourself constantly and try to just work harder. “It will get better” is some weird mantra people utter in whispers on Webex calls (afraid they are being recorded. Complicated compensation plans- good luck trying to figure out how you get paid Unlimited PTO- that no one feels comfortable taking A company who tells clients how to “win the war on talent and reduce turnover” who lays people off left and right, hiring high school grads so they can pay them less, and who has seriously high turnover because what they were told in the interview doesn’t resemble the actuality of the role…. Touts the flex tech stack and then buys Paycor because….well….the flex tech stack isn’t as good (we know). And yet- it’s hard to leave. It’s hard to leave when you believed what they were saying- but when you do it’s like the biggest freshest breath of crisp, clean air. There is a whole world outside of Paychex- go explore.

Viewing 391 - 393 of 5,990 Reviews

Glassdoor has 6,162 Paychex reviews submitted anonymously by Paychex employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if Paychex is right for you.